Rebecca Maizel. New York: St, Martin's Griffin,
2013. 304 pp.
Rating: Decent
**Spoiler Alert: This review contains mild spoilers.**
After surviving the ritual
she performed to restore Vicken's humanity, Lenah returns to Wickham's campus.
Upon her return, Lenah witnesses a horrendous, yet familiar
act. However, before processing the latest scene, Lenah encounters the
legendary Aeris. Their visit is most unexpected, but it doesn't compare to the
live, very mortal figure of Rhode Lewin. Lost in the moment, Lenah forgets
Justin's presence at her side, though she quickly discovers Rhode's
reappearance comes at a price. Amid the turmoil, a formidable opponent reveals
itself. A foe more powerful than her coven, the aspiring vampire queen Odette.
I had several issues with
this book, but let's begin with the bright spot—Vicken. His witty,
snarky, and sarcastic comments are always delivered at the right times. Ok,
on to the issues.
Issue
one: Lenah Beaudonte. With every flip of the page, I wanted to smack some sense
into her.
Lenah's selfishness and
teenage angst is too much to bear. She annoys to the point of
dislike, not to mention her irritating internal monologue. Lenah's actions
make it difficult to determine whether she is unable, unwilling, or indifferent
to the lives tied to her own. With each bad decision, those closest to her and
the Wickham community suffer devastating consequences.
Issue two: The love triangle. I'm not a big fan of love triangles because rather than enhancing a story, most often it distracts, detracts, and occasionally takes over the plot, which is exactly what happens--plot hijacked. "Yes, Lenah Beaudonte. You and Rhode Lewin
were born under the same stars. The course of your lives has brought you here—together, as soul mates"
(14). Lenah's obsession with Rhode's lack of
attention pushes her to Justin, the consolation prize, in which she
attempts to alleviate her hurt, although their relationship isn't as it
had been previously. "It
seemed to me then I'd never again feel the joy and comfort of lying in his
arms. I remembered how powerful his warmth had felt after being cold
for hundreds of years. Warmth, touch, tenderness—that was Justin.
He was a reminder that I could truly be alive and feel love. He'd helped
me move on last year. I wanted him to help me now. Help me in the way only he
could" (82). It irks me that Lenah picks back up with Justin sparing no
regard for his feelings. Plus, her need to be wanted causes her to be careless
and impulsive. Instead of harnessing energy to defeat Odette, Lenah
pines for her first love and buries herself in his alternate. It's not until the last few chapters where Lenah is able reign in
her emotions. Yet, she fails to separate her affection for Justin from the
danger he imposes.
Issue three: Discrepancies.
While visiting the graveyard of her childhood home in 1730, etched in
Lenah's tombstone are the dates 1400-1417 (24), which is completely
inconsistent from book one where Rhode kills Lenah at the age of fifteen in
1418. "I was almost 16, had never left my parents' orchard, and the most
beautiful man in the world stood in from of me." (Infinite Days,
49) Also, the epilogue hints toward Justin being a vampire and responsible for
student disappearances, which wouldn't make sense according to the
Aeris' statement to Lenah, "Every person you murdered will live
again, as will those killed by the vampires you created. They will never meet
you—because you won't become a vampire. It will be as though you had never
met" (16).
After such a long wait, I was
disappointed in the novel, which differed greatly from the snippet included in
the back of book one; and the deviation of the storyline from such a promising
start in the series. Vicken, along with the last three chapters saved the
book. Even though I didn't like Stolen Nights as much
as Infinite Days, I will continue on with the series because it
started so strong and I believe that it could have a great finish.
To view my review of Infinite Days.
To view my review of Infinite Days.
OMG yes to everything you said. Like my review said, I was so fed up with Lenah and her yo-yo feelings that I just couldn't finish it. I feel bad for fans of Infinite Days andwaited years for Stolen Nights and it ended up being so disappointing. I only had a few months wait so it wasn't as bad.
ReplyDeleteSince I didn't finish the book I didn't know that the ending was left open for a 3rd book and to be honest, I don't even know if I were to pick it up. Hopefully, it'll make up for this book.
Thanks so much for stopping by my review!
Jenn @ Books and Swoons.
I'm hoping Book 3, Eternal Dawn, will salvage the series. It's expected release is July 3rd.
DeleteAnytime! I know all bloggers are just like me and love comments!! :-)